Japanese patent-infringement lawsuit follows “investigation” announced in January.
Nintendo and The Pokemon Company announced they have filed a patent-infringement lawsuit against Pocketpair, the makers of the heavily Pokémon-inspired Palworld. The Tokyo District Court lawsuit seeks an injunction and damages “on the grounds that Palworld infringes multiple patent rights,” according to the announcement.
“Nintendo will continue to take necessary actions against any infringement of its intellectual property rights including the Nintendo brand itself, to protect the intellectual properties it has worked hard to establish over the years,” the company writes.
Further Reading
Defining Tetris: How courts judge gaming clonesThe many surface similarities between Pokémon and Palworld are readily apparent, even though Pocketpair’s game adds many new features over Nintendo’s (such as, uh, guns). But making legal hay over even heavy common ground between games can be an uphill battle. That’s because copyright law (at least in the US) generally doesn’t apply to a game’s mere design elements, and only extends to “expressive elements” such as art, character design, and music.
Further Reading
Attacking the clones: indie game devs fight blatant rip-offsGenerally, even blatant rip-offs of successful games are able to make just enough changes to those “expressive” portions to avoid any legal trouble. But Palworld might clear the high legal bar for infringement if the game’s 3D character models were indeed lifted almost wholesale from actual Pokémon game files, as some observers have been alleging since January.
What patent are we talking about?
Beyond mere copyright concerns, though, Nintendo’s lawsuit announcement specifically alleges patent infringement on the part of Palworld (though this difference could come down to vagaries of translation from the original Japanese). A lawsuit over patents would seemingly require some unique game mechanic or feature that has been specifically granted stronger protections by the patent office. While the Pokémon Company does hold a number of (US) patents, most of them seem to deal with various server communications methods or the sleep monitoring capabilities of Pokémon Sleep.
Ars Video
What Happens to the Developers When AI Can Code? | Ars Frontiers
“Palworld is such a different type of game from Pokémon, it’s hard to imagine what patents (*not* copyrights) might have been even plausibly infringed,” game industry attorney Richard Hoeg posted on social media Wednesday night. “Initial gut reaction is Nintendo may be reaching.”
PocketPair CEO Takuro Mizobe told Automaton Media in January that the game had “cleared legal reviews” and that “we have absolutely no intention of infringing upon the intellectual property of other companies.”
Further Reading
Pokémon Company will “investigate” Palworld in light of plagiarism accusationsShortly after Palworld became a viral mega-hit on Steam in January, Nintendo said that it would “investigate and take appropriate measures” against “another [then-unnamed] company’s game released in January 2024.” Those measures are now moving forward even as Palworld‘s initial burst of popularity has given way to more modest player numbers in recent months.
Update (Sept. 19, 2024): In a statement posted overnight, Pocketpair said it was currently “unaware of the specific patents we are accused of infringing upon, and have not been notified of such details. The company went on to lament, “It is truly unfortunate that we will be forced to allocate significant time to matters unrelated to game development due to this lawsuit. However, we will do our utmost for our fans, and to ensure that indie game developers are not hindered or discouraged from pursuing their creative ideas.”
Pocketpair promises that it “will continue improving Palworld and strive to create a game that our fans can be proud of.”
